[3] I watched it. Honestly it was long winded/unnecessarily wordy, and if I think that, I’m confident most others won’t watch it all.
[2] It’s still early days so as Frederic said “The Voltaire roadmap will likely shed better light on dependancies, relationships and symbiosis between parts.”.
For the time being the CIP is great as an interim, but I hope it improves.
[1] In my opinion, at this moment I feel ideally this process shouldn’t require admins (CIP Editors) or some kind of hierarchy, because then there is a power system created that can be abused or biassed.
If this process will become the ‘final’ process, the maximum the CIP Editors should be there for is to help edit the CIP in to the correct subtext. They shouldn’t be making subjective decisions as to whether a CIP is valid, in their opinion or not.
Just theoretically: If CIP’s are being blocked for subjective reasons, before they get to democratic vote, then it’s not a democratic system.