OutputTooSmallUTxO with 5652098 lovelace

CardanoValley · 18 May 2021 17:58

I know that we are supposed to transfer at least 1 $ADA when we send an NFT and to be sure one can transfer 2 (it seems to be the standard right now).

But for some reason, even though I transfer 2 $ADA, cardano-cli seems to have problems with the 5652098 lovelace (5.6 $ADA) that remain in my txin when transaction finishes

UtxoFailure (OutputTooSmallUTxO [(Addr Mainnet (KeyHashObj (KeyHash "79ffb6422c51071ca861206a572aa0f1568b2c605db5c8b024a71b55")) StakeRefNull,Value 5652098

If you need I can share the cardano-cli command, just let me know.

I checked that my balance is ok 8095751 initial funds−443653 (fee)−5652098 (remains)−2000000 (transferred with NFT) = 0

Any ideas? Thanks in advance!

laplasz · 18 May 2021 20:03

Hi!

please share the command, and the whole error

CardanoValley · 18 May 2021 20:28

Sure. No problem. First you need to know that I managed to solve it.

This was the command

cardano-cli transaction build-raw --fee 443653 --out-file 210518_143421566_mgmn_genesis_funding_tx.body --tx-in d7c671df4b5e9a2dc1641346f16c9021509aaa3d0640b27e32c1035562650fa7#0 \

--tx-out addr1v9ulldjz93gsw89gvysx54e25rc4dzevvpwmtj9syjn3k4gumfcs3+5652098+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04695+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi06594+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi05946+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi02633+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi08469+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi06710+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi01876+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.CardagotchiOvoOnoM01349+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchiindianamith02243+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04571+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi00649+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04103+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi08842+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi06999+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.CardagotchiInti01997+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi03332+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi00648+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi03571+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi06070+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi03274+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi02410+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04387+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.CardagotchiMrIntangble09391+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchicandle06394+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi07539+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04138+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi01481+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi09490+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi05201+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi08985+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.CardagotchiCharlyHosken01021+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04971+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi07621+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi02237+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi06674+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi00785+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi04520+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi02642+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi08050 \

--tx-out addr1q9254euy7ms7kevvz4s5zj5aypz0e3twhy39eyln97wrn37l8pd0p8a6n368nden5tw7jttkfqhgk7g20mgv7cwq2zds5panyl+2000000+1 1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7.Cardagotchi00641

This was the whole error:

cardano_clusterlib.clusterlib.CLIError: An error occurred running a CLI command `cardano-cli transaction submit --mainnet --tx-file 210518_153259933_vgwc_genesis_funding_tx.signed --cardano-mode` on path `/home/gabriel/Documents/workspace/cardano-minter`: Command failed: transaction submit  Error: Error while submitting tx: ShelleyTxValidationError ShelleyBasedEraMary (ApplyTxError [UtxowFailure (UtxoFailure (OutputTooSmallUTxO [(Addr Mainnet (KeyHashObj (KeyHash "79ffb6422c51071ca861206a572aa0f1568b2c605db5c8b024a71b55")) StakeRefNull,Value 4652098 (fromList [(PolicyID {policyID = ScriptHash "1746ee8096f7f1da9c1858a3254db610106e0d9cc42fce300d5e2ed7"},fromList [("Cardagotchi00648",1),("Cardagotchi00649",1),("Cardagotchi00785",1),("Cardagotchi01481",1),("Cardagotchi01876",1),("Cardagotchi02237",1),("Cardagotchi02410",1),("Cardagotchi02633",1),("Cardagotchi02642",1),("Cardagotchi03274",1),("Cardagotchi03332",1),("Cardagotchi03571",1),("Cardagotchi04103",1),("Cardagotchi04138",1),("Cardagotchi04387",1),("Cardagotchi04520",1),("Cardagotchi04571",1),("Cardagotchi04695",1),("Cardagotchi04971",1),("Cardagotchi05201",1),("Cardagotchi05946",1),("Cardagotchi06070",1),("Cardagotchi06594",1),("Cardagotchi06674",1),("Cardagotchi06710",1),("Cardagotchi06999",1),("Cardagotchi07539",1),("Cardagotchi07621",1),("Cardagotchi08050",1),("Cardagotchi08469",1),("Cardagotchi08842",1),("Cardagotchi08985",1),("Cardagotchi09490",1),("CardagotchiCharlyHosken01021",1),("CardagotchiInti01997",1),("CardagotchiMrIntangble09391",1),("CardagotchiOvoOnoM01349",1),("Cardagotchicandle06394",1),("Cardagotchiindianamith02243",1)])]))]))])

To solve it what I did was adding another --tx-in with the money to pay the fee and I left the txin with the tokens with the same amount.

Interesting right?

laplasz · 18 May 2021 20:38

Great!

Hope this help for others as well…

CardanoValley · 19 May 2021 02:44

yep. Do you know if I’m supposed to create a bug ticket for this? Doesn’t sound like a good behaviour.
Furthermore I managed to do more NFT transfers and I even left the auxiliar txin with less ADA than the one with the NFTs and it’s still working so… this has no sense.
What do you guys think?

laplasz · 19 May 2021 18:31

So, would be great to see first what was the solution - right now I can not understand it fully…
but yes, you can raise a ticket on zendesk, and hope you get a proper answer…
https://iohk.zendesk.com/hc/en-us

_ilap · 19 May 2021 22:33

You need to calculate the minimum ada for the transaction, as you have a lot of tokens in your tx.
I think you need around 6.6ADA for this.

Check this

github.com

input-output-hk/cardano-ledger-specs/blob/master/doc/explanations/min-utxo.rst

Min-Ada-Value Requirement
==============================

Min-Ada-Value Explanation
##########################

Recall that UTxOs on the ledger may contain a heterogeneous collection of tokens, including ada.
Ada is a limited resource in the Cardano system. Requiring some amount of ada to be included
in every UTxO (where that amount is based on the size of the UTxO, in bytes),
limits the maximum total size taken up by UTxO entries on the ledger at a given time.

The maximum possible UTxO size (the sum of the sizes of all UTxO entries) is implicitly adjusted by raising and
lowering the min-ada-value parameter. In this way, the constraint protects the Cardano ledger
from growing past a certain size. A ledger without a size bound is vulnerable to
being populated by so much data that users will unable to process it (or run a node) with
machines meeting the recommended specifications for running a node.

The Ada-only Case
###########################

This file has been truncated. show original

CardanoValley · 20 May 2021 13:30

min-ada-value

Thanks for answering.
min-ada-value paramter is about 1 ADA right now. Am I right?
How can I calculate what you said? How did you came up with 6.6 ADA number? I thought the fee value + the min-ada-value was enough for the transaction to work

_ilap · 21 May 2021 04:34

I am very busy atm but will respond you in 6hrs
UPDATED:
You need to check the calculation in the bottom of the page I sent.

Freja · 21 May 2021 09:56

I don’t think this is a bug. As @_ilap wrote you will need a bit more ada in the utxo with the remaining tokens. When you try to transfer one token with 2 ada you don’t have enough ada left for the utxo with the other tokens (5.7 something). When you took the 2 ada from another wallet then you have enough ada for both utxos
1 ada is the min value but when you have many tokens in the same utxo you need more than that.

(also I think there will be a way to calculate the exact amount in the cli-tool now, but I have not tried yet. I usually just add some extra ada on top so I don’t need to bother)

CardanoValley · 15 June 2021 20:55

thanks! I get it now.

timeforprunejuice · 18 June 2021 18:29

FYI, I tried to empty an account and could not. I had the same error OutPutTooSmallUTxO. I had to increase the differnce from 500000 lovelace to 1.5 ADA. It was finally a successful transaction, but left 1.5 ada in the account tha tI may not be able to recover …

CardanoValley · 19 June 2021 00:14

1.5 ADA without any tokens present in the wallet?

Topic		Replies	Views
Small transaction failing with error - OutputTooSmallUTxO Community Technical Support transactions	10	1297	21 June 2021
NFT minimum UTxO Native Tokens cardano , developers , native-tokens	8	1790	28 April 2021
Cannot send a NFT Native Tokens	13	2121	29 June 2021
ValueNotConservedUTxO with 1input 1 output Community Technical Support	8	2020	22 September 2021
Create a transaction to send only a small amount of available lovelace - cardano-cli Misc Dev Talk cardano	2	662	30 October 2021

OutputTooSmallUTxO with 5652098 lovelace

Related Topics