Suggestions and feedback for our Help Centre!


#10

Can you please include the link under “Resources” too, it will be helpful to newcomers.

help%20center


#11

Great idea and much needed. I would suggest that because the user experience on different setups for Daedalus can be wildly different, that there be an optimal setup suggested. For instance, I can not make my wallet crash in any scenario I have tried on my Mac with the update, yet others are having issues. I would clearly state that Daedalus is not just a lite wallet but that the user will be running a full node. (Exciting!) Therefore, optimally we suggest for X operating system that your configuration includes Y. With the caveat as the wallet gets updated it will become more flexible, and this will become obsolete. Not sure if this reasonable and would assist some of the issues people have had, but it’s an idea. It may be too complicated.

Thanks for all your hard work. I’m enjoying watching your progress.


#12

@Jam35x Great idea, I will make this change.


#13

How about adding a new collection with al video and press material in the articles.

You could name it Education.

Charles Hoskinson interviews
Whiteboard videos
IOHK videos
Community made videos
Mentions in press
Wikipedia articles about cardano and PoS
Whitepapers with direct links
Community guidelines
Etc…

This would allow for a broader search to be used in the help center (currently, you will find zero results if you search for whitepaper for example).

Ideally you want the structure the be a search tool for help, as well as a shortcut to finding everything related to cardano. Making it more of a help / knowledge base tool.

This would also improve your SEO when people search for anything related to general cryptocurrency lexicon.

Some more ideas for collections:

  • Trading
  • dApp development (too soon to implement, I know… That is going to be a very good day :slight_smile: )

#14

@Bullish You got some cool ideas. :+1:


#15

in short: good idea and highly useful
Also mentioning a lot of altcoins, concepts, ideas, with some “discrete” mentions of known problems/issues/drawbacks is great.

I agree with all written by @Bullish
Please keep in mind to write the articles in a way that supporting community members can easily copy the link and use it as a short answer. I mean: have one topic <=> one url.
I bet such pages will be also frequently used in third-party content like blog posts, tweets, sub-text links in youtube, …

If a certain topic is more complex it shouldn’t be divided into multiple pages. In such cases, it would be great when each subheader/section on that page has an #anchor link

For example look at this existing article
https://help.cardano.org/why-cardano/introduction/motivation

When I want to point someone to the “social phenomenon” arguments I could use the above link and add “then scroll down to …”
Or if there would be an anchor link I could point directly to https://help.cardano.org/why-cardano/introduction/motivation#social-phenomenon
Nothing crucial but if the content management system support anchors I would recommend to place them.

practically, the entire “help centre” is mainly an “education centre” and that’s good.

@cf_maki.mukai
I don’t know CFs internal human resources but if you have some talented illustrator or you can hire someone externally you should invest in some little “whiteboard style” graphics to loosen up the texts. you know a pic often says more than thousands of words. And a lot of people are allergic to reading more than two sentences.


#16

Spot on Markus, well said! Good design is infectious and keeps users engaged…

Big fan of using anchors as they would deliver a better user experience and functionality to direct people to the proper sections.


#17

Hi @cf_maki.mukai ,
I would like to recommend a correction to one of the Help Centre subjects that appears to be in error, with screen captures below to show the correction. The subject is “Can you run two wallets on the same computer?” and the answer is “It is possible to run two wallets on the same computer, but you would need to do this using separate user accounts.” The answer is in error, because you can easily run 2 wallets on the same computer and user account because Daedalus is designed to create multiple wallets in the same instance using the + sign.

So maybe the question should be “Can I run more than 1 instance of Daedalus on the same computer?” and then that answer would be correct. Below is a screen capture where I created 2 additional wallets for a total of 3 wallets on the same computer account. You can use it for reference if you like.

I do software testing and documentation for my work on occasion, so I will go through more of the help centre when I have time to check for errors. Hope this helps.

~Rick


#18

Good point @rickymac , especially because people not so familiar with blockchain, cardano or daedalus, could easily get confused , resulting in a strange feeling if their wallets are safe.
Having a small illustration how cardano main nodes, local instances and the wallet(s) on the same or multiple computer accounts are organized would help.

But this depends also a bit on the release date of Shalley and it’s impact on this diagram. From my understanding it will be a multiple step release and conversion to a quite different diagram with staking pools ( and then also light wallets)


#19

@Jam35x Change has been made:


#20

@cf_tom.kelly Much Appreciated!


#21

I would love a guide for how people can try out Cardano without using real ADA.

In particular, I haven’t seen an answer on these forums regarding the best way for people to interact with a testnet or launch their own testnet with available fake ADA:




#22

Hi @rickymac,

I think there is some confusion, which comes from the lazy definitions of almost everything in the space.

  • Wallet only means a Public/Private key pair.
  • They meant Daedalus (the app/program) when they referred to Wallet.
  • Daedalus can have multiple Wallets derivated from the root Public/Private keys (as it uses Hierarchical deterministic keys), see:Cardano’s HD Wallets

But, Why I do not recommend to have multiple Daedalus app/program on the same computer is the following:

  • The Daedalus has two parts: Frontend (Electron GUI) and and Backend (a full node w/ ReST API).
  • Backend uses localhost’s port 8090 to allow connections from any clients.
  • If a node is running on a Computer, you cannot start another Daedalus as the other full node is already listening on that port.

I explain why this is a problem.
So, if you start your Daedalus /w your account and your lock your computer, and somebody that can access to the same computer by switching (not log out/log in but switching) user and he/she starts a Daedalus, then she /he will be very surprised as she/he will see your wallets in the started Daedalous.:slight_smile:

So, Daedalus should use some basic auth or some client certificate to allow a connection at least.


Using Daedalus Wallet on a diff computeer
#23

This is not possible as Daedalus wallet data is stored in %appdata% folder of respective users.


#24

I do not want to argue, so I have tested my theory (it’s not a theory it’s a fact how hybrid TCP/IP stack works) on my Macbook Pro, by

  • creating a testuser,
  • started the Daedalus on my primary account then
  • switched (switched and not logged out, that’s important) to the testuser,
  • started a new Daedalus that stores their RocksDB and other stuffs under testuser’s ~/Library/Application Support/Daedalus and
  • voala I could see my primary’s acocunt w/ the relevant amount of ADA and, even the transactions.

There is no any magic in it to someone who knows how TCP/IP Networking works as Daedalus stores its metadata in the backend, the issue is w/ the Design decisions themselves.


#25

The trick is that the Daedalus frontend (testuser’s) connects to an already running backend (the original user’s full node where all the data, metadata are stored).:slight_smile:


#26

Oh, I forget to mention, when the Daedalus starts on the testuser’s account you need to select the language and agree on the Term’s and Conditions, after that you will see the magic.


#27

That’s a bit scary! :fearful: Maybe it deserves a new topic in Developers?


#28

@_ilap, that’s pretty cool you experimented and tested that on your computer, that the primary wallet showed up. Also, at the same time, I still think I am correct in saying the web page is not accurate, as the Daedalus wallet allows a user to make multiple wallets inside the same wallet. That is why I think they need to change the web page to say “another instance” or “more than 1 instance” of Daedalus which is different than running 2 or more wallets inside the same single instance of Daedalus.


#29

Thank you for the detailed description. I can’t test it at the moment because not in front of my PC, but are you 100% sure that the wallet keys are stored on the local node and not the frontends file system folder?

I always understood the current Daedalus implementation as an intermediate (beta) solution before they became clearly separated into staking pools and (light) wallets.
IMHO many users simply expect to use a wallet app the same way as they have for other altcoins, and don’t know about the “proxy-node” running on their PC.